Difference Between Izod and Charpy Test

testing impact strength methods

Discover the mind-blowing disparities between the Izod and Charpy tests, the ultimate determinants of material impact resistance. Brace yourself for a riveting exploration of the striking dissimilarities in test setup, specimen position, notch type, hammer type, notch position, strike point, and specimen dimensions.

This article unveils the hidden secrets that researchers, engineers, and manufacturers crave to make informed decisions. Don't miss out on this eye-opening revelation, as we delve into the crucial nuances of the Izod and Charpy tests, providing you with unparalleled control over material selection and design.

Key Takeaways

  • The Izod test and Charpy test have different specimen positions, with the Izod test placing the specimen vertically and the Charpy test placing it horizontally.
  • The Charpy test offers V-notch and U-notch options for the notch type, while the Izod test only uses V-notch. The choice of notch type can affect the measurement of impact strength.
  • The Izod test uses a farming hammer as the striker, while the Charpy test uses a ball pin hammer. The choice of hammer type is crucial for obtaining accurate and reliable results.
  • The notch position and strike point differ between the Izod and Charpy tests, with the notch face facing the striker in the Izod test and positioned away from the striker in the Charpy test. This orientation affects the specimen's response to impact and influences stress concentrations and fracture behavior.

Test Setup and Specimen Position

The test setup for both the Izod and Charpy tests involves positioning the specimen in a specific orientation and location within the testing apparatus. In the Izod test, the specimen is placed vertically, and the hammer strikes the upper tip of the specimen. The notch face faces the striker. The dimensions of the Izod test specimen are 75 x 10 x 10mm.

On the other hand, in the Charpy test, the specimen is placed horizontally, and the hammer strikes the point of the notch in the opposite direction. The notch face is positioned away from the striker. The dimensions of the Charpy test specimen are 55 x 10 x 10mm.

One advantage of the Izod test is its ability to measure the impact resistance of materials in various orientations. However, a disadvantage of the Charpy test is that it may not accurately reflect the behavior of materials in certain applications.

Notch Type

Characterized by a V-notch for the Charpy test and solely a V-notch for the Izod test, the notch type plays a significant role in determining the impact strength of materials.

The Charpy test offers two options for notches, the V-notch and the U-notch. On the other hand, the Izod test only uses the V-notch.

The choice of notch type can affect the results of the impact resistance comparison between different materials. The V-notch is commonly used because it provides a more reliable and consistent measurement of impact strength.

The U-notch, although less commonly used, can still provide valuable information in certain situations.

When comparing the impact resistance of materials, it is important to consider the notch type used in the test to ensure accurate and meaningful results.

Hammer Type

Both the Izod test and the Charpy test use different hammers to strike the specimen.

In the Izod test, they use a farming hammer as the striker, while in the Charpy test, they use a ball pin hammer.

The farming hammer is made of sturdy material to withstand the force applied during the test. It is designed to deliver a controlled and precise strike to the specimen.

On the other hand, the ball pin hammer used in the Charpy test also has a strong and durable construction. It is specifically chosen for its ability to deliver a concentrated force to the specimen.

The choice of hammer material and striker force is crucial in ensuring accurate and reliable test results in both the Izod and Charpy tests.

Notch Position and Strike Point

Regarding the positioning of the notch and the point of strike, the Izod test requires the notch face to be facing the striker while the Charpy test positions the notch face away from the striker. This difference in notch face orientation has an effect on the test results.

Here are three key points to consider:

  1. Notch face orientation: In the Izod test, the notch face faces the striker, which means that the impact occurs directly on the notch. In contrast, in the Charpy test, the notch face is positioned away from the striker, causing the impact to occur on the opposite side of the notch. This difference in orientation affects how the specimen responds to the impact.
  2. Effect of notch type on test results: Both the Izod and Charpy tests use different types of notches. The Charpy test uses V-notch and U-notch configurations, while the Izod test only uses V-notch. The different notch types can influence the test results, as they introduce different stress concentrations and may lead to variations in fracture behavior.
  3. Control of the testing process: The positioning of the notch and strike point in both tests allows for control over the point of impact and the orientation of the specimen. This control is crucial in ensuring consistent and reliable test results, as it eliminates variables that could affect the outcome of the test.

Miscellaneous

In addition to the differences in test setup, notch type, and hammer type, there are several miscellaneous factors that distinguish the Izod and Charpy tests. These factors include the specimen dimensions and the impact of temperature on test results.

The Izod test uses a specimen with dimensions of 75 x 10 x 10mm, while the Charpy test uses a specimen with dimensions of 55 x 10 x 10mm. This difference in specimen size can affect the test results and the interpretation of the data.

Furthermore, the impact of temperature on the test results is an important consideration. The Izod and Charpy tests can be conducted at different temperatures to evaluate the material's performance under different conditions. However, it is important to note that the test results can be influenced by the temperature at which the test is conducted.

Table: Miscellaneous Factors

Factor Izod Test Charpy Test
Specimen Dimensions 75 x 10 x 10mm 55 x 10 x 10mm
Impact of Temperature Results influenced by test temperature Results influenced by test temperature

Comparison of Test Specimen Dimensions

Neither the Izod test nor the Charpy test utilize the same dimensions for their test specimens. The test specimen size plays a crucial role in determining the impact resistance of a material. Here are three key differences in the test specimen dimensions between the Izod and Charpy test:

  1. Izod test specimen dimensions: The Izod test requires a specimen size of 75 x 10 x 10mm. This larger size allows for a more comprehensive evaluation of the material's impact resistance.
  2. Charpy test specimen dimensions: In contrast, the Charpy test uses a smaller specimen size of 55 x 10 x 10mm. This smaller size allows for a quicker and more efficient testing process.
  3. Impact test methods: The difference in test specimen size influences the impact test methods used for the Izod and Charpy tests. While both tests measure the energy absorbed by the specimen upon impact, the varying specimen dimensions require specific test setups and strike points to ensure accurate results.

Understanding these differences in test specimen dimensions is essential in selecting the appropriate impact test method for evaluating material properties.

Leave a Reply

Share this post

You May Also Like